Banoffee: what is it, what does it look like and how does it reinvent meat with roasted platters on the grill?

There are desserts that everyone knows and desserts with a mystery. Banoffee is one of the second: a combination of banana and toffee that is popular in an English restaurant for more than fifty years, which is going to become a classic of British confectionery and which, both times, has been adopted by many adopting several different versions.

At Carnal Steakhouse we give it our own twist: a creamy roasted banana banoffee with rum salted caramel and peanut brittle. But before we get to our version, the origin story is worth telling.

The origin of banoffee pie in an English restaurant in 1971

Banoffee was born in 1971 at The Hungry Monk, a restaurant in Jevington, a village in East Sussex, southern England. Nigel Mackenzie, the owner, and Ian Dowding, the chef, were looking for a new dessert and came across a recipe in an American magazine for Blum's Coffee Toffee Pie, a tart built on boiled condensed milk that turned into a thick caramel.

They started experimenting. They tried apple, mandarin orange, but nothing quite worked. Then Mackenzie suggested banana. Dowding tried it and later recalled, "straight away we knew we had got it right." The combination of banana, condensed-milk caramel (what Latin America calls dulce de leche) and whipped cream was a perfect match.

Mackenzie coined the name by merging banana and toffee. The recipe was published in 1974 in The Deeper Secrets of The Hungry Monk, and the dessert became so popular that the restaurant could never take it off the menu. In 1984, when British supermarkets began selling it labelled as an American pie, Mackenzie offered £10,000 to anyone who could disprove their claim to have invented it. Nobody came forward.

Anatomy of a classic pastry recipe

The original recipe is simple. The base is shortcrust pastry (Dowding famously disliked biscuit-crumb bases, though they are more common today). On top, a generous layer of condensed-milk caramel, fresh banana slices and whipped cream. Some versions add chocolate, coffee or both, but the classic stands on three elements: the sweetness of the caramel, the freshness of the banana and the lightness of the cream.

Our version: charcoal-roasted banana and rum salted caramel

At Carnal, the grill is not just a technique for meat: it is the restaurant's identity. And when we set out to create a dessert that could close a dinner on the same level, it made sense to put the banana over the same wood-fired grill we use for every cut.

There is a widespread assumption that in a meat restaurant desserts are an afterthought, a formality before asking for the bill. That is a mistake: a dinner with character, a fine aged-beef cut and a carefully selected glass of wine deserves a closing course that lives up to what came before.

If you want to discover what banoffee tastes like when the banana has been over a wood-fired grill, you can book a table at Carnal Steakhouse and order it as the finale to your dinner. We look forward to welcoming you at Enric Granados 52, in the heart of Barcelona's Eixample.